Increasing Penetration of BEVs Overcapacity or opportunity for cast aluminium?
Improving battery technology and forthcoming regulation of internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles are boosting the outlook for the electric vehicle (EV). EV components offer new opportunities for the aluminium foundries.
But should the battery electric vehicle (BEV) share rise considerably faster than that of the plug-in-hybrid electric vehicle (PHEV) and the full hybrid vehicle (HV) combined? An overcapacity could hit aluminium foundries by the end of the next decade. Electric vehicle (EV) battery prices are falling faster than expected and consumer cost of ownership could reach parity with internal combustion engine (ICE) as early as 2018 in Europe [USB]. Forecasts for EVs are revised upwards as its technology is improving, promising longer range and shorter charging time in the near future. In the meantime, the list of countries imposing regulations or even a ban of ICE vehicles is getting longer. The Netherlands and India have just recently announced a complete sales ban of ICE vehicles from 2025 and 2030 respectively, while China and the EU have a sales quote system on the agenda for PHEVs and BEVs.
If indeed the next generation of BEVs will have a range of +400 km, charging times of about 15 minutes and cost parity with ICEs are met due to falling battery prices, the penetration of BEVs will increase rapidly. Looking at the latest projections from 24 different automotive forecasting institutes and tier suppliers, a worldwide BEV penetration of 6,86% (range between 2% - 15%) is expected by 2025, growing to 18,56% (range between 5,75% - 34%) in 2030.
Overcapacity could hit aluminium foundries
Alu-Mag Automotive is continuously analysing the consumption of lightweight materials in automotive applications. Lightweight materials like aluminum, magnesium and carbon fibre are currently in high demand, as low weight equals longer range or a reduction of the battery cost for an electric vehicle. But the fast developing BEV segment could lead to overcapacity in the aluminum casting industry around 2025-2030.
Especially foundries (casting entities) serving the powertrain segment, together with peripheral components such as pump housings, are in the danger zone. To cope with the additional demand for HV and PHEV cast aluminium components, capacity has and is being added by the foundries as well as by screw, hose and pipe manufacturers, some of which will become redundant as the BEV share increases. BEVs contain much less cast aluminium in the powertrain area compared to ICE vehicles, HVs and PHEVs. Engine components like cylinder blocks/heads, oil-pans, turbochargers, manifolds are not needed on a BEV.
And although BEVs feature cast aluminium as well as intensive powertrain applications (motor housings, inverters, converters, chargers and stator housings, etc.), they are expected to shed around 35-40kg of cast aluminium within the powertrain area compared to the average Northern American ICE vehicle – somewhat less, compared to European ICE vehicle. For PHEVs, the difference in the cast aluminium powertrain utilisation is even higher, considering PHEV applications like electric motor, battery and power electronic housings. Should cast aluminium become the preferred solution to house the battery on BEVs, the difference in the cast aluminium utilisation would be narrowed down considerably. At the moment though, steel or hybrid solutions seem to be preferred by OEMs.
Furthermore, heating, cooling, steering, brake or recuperation, assistance systems, door closers, windows, etc. are or will be electrified, which will decrease the demand for cast aluminum further. In addition, cast aluminum is under pressure from other materials like for example, Aramid-reinforced plastics that replace zinc and aluminum die casting in the small-parts sector such as belt tensioners, filter housings or brackets, etc.
For a state of overcapacity to occur, it is important to note that the BEV share has to grow considerably faster than that of the PHEV and full HV combined. Otherwise the decreasing demand for cast aluminium created by the growing penetration of BEVs would be compensated by the increasing demand for PHEV and full HV applications. Furthermore, some regions like Africa, Russia and parts of Asia are not likely to be hit because a low penetration of BEVs is expected.
Structural applications – a growing segment
One may argue that the increasing use of cast aluminum for structural applications will more than offset a possible declining demand for powertrain applications. Structural cast-aluminum applications are being used increasingly in premium segments for applications such as suspension domes, longitudinal carriers, cross-members, doors/gates and A-B-C pillars. In Europe, the demand for structural cast-aluminum applications increased by around 65% in 2017. The high growth rate in this segment has not gone unnoticed, which has resulted in several new entries the last couple of years (Bocar, Cosma, Nemak, 2a, Mercury) – profiting from a growing segment but also diversifying its business away from ICE powertrain applications.
But it is questionable whether the increasing demand for structural cast-aluminum applications will more than offset the dropping demand for cast-aluminum applications expected due to the increasing penetration of BEVs. So far, there has only been a few samples of structural cast-aluminum applications within the D-segment. Furthermore, hybrid body structures are being increasingly utilised by premium OEMs instead of full aluminum bodies. Audi's latest generation A8 D5 (body weight of 621 pounds has 58% aluminum) was launched with a hybrid structure, resulting in a heavier body compared to the outgoing A8 D4 (body weight of 509 pounds with 92% aluminum) aluminum structure.
The increasing penetration of the BEV is/was expected to boost the demand for lightweight materials in structural application even further, but the fast developing battery technology has and could have a negative impact on the OEMs' willingness to implement these materials. When the BMW I3 was launched back in 2013, it made sense for BMW to invest in the CFRP cell for the I3, as a lighter car needs a smaller battery. The battery is the most expensive part of an electric car and the cost saved on the battery could be invested in the frame. In the meantime, advances in electric vehicle battery technology have improved vehicle operating ranges by more than 50% since 2013, taking some pressure off the need to use ultra-lightweight materials like carbon fibre in the manufacturing process. Although aluminum and CFRP can`t be compared, projected advancements in battery technology could/will limit the use of structural cast-aluminum applications too.
Two-thirds of the consumers consider 300-mile/480-km range on a single charge as sufficient. [USB Study]. Next generation BEVs from VW, Nissan, Daimler and BMW are expected to have a range of up to 500-600 km. Solid-state batteries as announced by Toyota, BMW and VW will increase the range even further and bring charging times down to “a few minutes”. If solid-state batteries perform as projected by the OEMs when they are launched around 2022, one of the main incentives to use lightweight-materials “powertrain efficiency” no longer fully apply and demand for automotive aluminum applications could decrease as a result.
Looking at newly launched BEVs like the Tesla Model 3, Chevrolet Bolt and Nissan Leaf, all feature a steel structure. The VW ID will, according to industry sources, become a steel structure with some components made of aluminum and magnesium and the next generation BMW I3 is said to lose its carbon/aluminum passenger cell/drive module. In fact, BMW and Benteler have de-invested from carbon engagement.
The technical commercial conditions are in place. Add that to a potentially global economic downturn, we could see a painful overcapacity in the aluminum foundry industry. Right now, we see over-heated markets and a consolidation is expected for the stock exchange, global economy, interest on capital, Chinese real estate, geo-political crisis and the automotive sector.
This article first appeared on www.spotlightmetal.com.